*warning - long post - skip down to the end for the important stuff! *
You guys are all to familiar with my dilemma with Dolly. She is a nice little mare - pretty, mostly easy to deal with on the ground, good size for me, good age, etc. etc., but I have been having confidence issues with her on the trail. That is pretty much the status quo for her and I.
2 weeks ago I went on trail ride with some other people from the barn. There were 9 horse/rider combos in total. I rode a pretty buckskin paint mare and a teenage girl rode Dolly. Dolly was wound up and acting a bit loony for the first 30 minutes of the ride and then slowly started to settle down. She had worked herself into a lather, doing all kinds of fancy dressage moves back and forth down the trail. Her rider just sat it out and didn't mind her antics at all. I was nervous just watching! lol After that ride, I was determined to sell her, as I knew I didn't have the seat or the nerves to sit out 30 minutes of antics when riding in a group.
Last week I finally had one response to her sale ad and the people found her on a recommendation from a local endurance rider. The guy came out to have a look at Dolly, who would maybe be his wife's horse to ride in local rides. I was very up front about why I was selling the horse and he wasn't concerned.
In the mean time, the barn owners had set me up with a trainer/coach that they thought could help Dolly and I, or at the least, tell me straight up whether he thought Dolly and I were a good match or not. I had him out on Saturday and we had a great chat about goals and my issues (nerves!!!!!!). He is also a sports coach, so he had lots of thoughts on mental training for the rider as well, which is more my issue than an actual problem with the horse.
He rode Dolly for about 45 minutes and he actually really liked her. She is super senstive in the bridle, which is a good thing, he thought. He started working on flexing and bending as he felt that she was very stiff and unbalanced (which
RuckusButt thought as well when she visited). I got on for a few minutes after he rode and could feel a bit of a difference in her mental state - if that makes any sense.
Coach Dan come out again on Sunday and we worked with Dolly for almost two hours (not all in the saddle). In that time, he had her doing a quiet western jog with her head all down and relaxed! I couldn't quite believe it, since she normally gets all excited at the trot - even in the ring - and has her head up in the air...
I got on for 15-20 minutes and we worked on some exercises at the walk so I could get a feel for how he was doing things. It felt like I was riding a totally different horse! I didn't try the trot or jog yet, since that will probably take some time for me to get...but I felt that maybe with some coaching we had a good chance to get over our issues.
And then, Sunday night, I got a call from the potential buyer and he wanted to come back with his wife this time! (Kudos to any readers that made it down this far to discover the actual "pickle" from the title! lol) I actually wavered a bit on whether or not to tell them that she is no longer for sale. I think we made some good progress in two sessions and could do a lot more over the summer, with regular coaching. On the other hand, I could still sell her and start fresh with another horse (which I have yet to find...).
Now, there is no guarantee that these people will buy her, but they are interested. I slept on the problem and when I woke up this morning, I still didn't have a clear idea of what to do. So, I called the potential buyer and told him that my price was firm and I wasn't negotiating and if he was still interested, he could come out and try her again. If they love her and are willing to pay my asking price, I'll probably let her go and chalk it up to experience and learning...maybe she will be "the one that got away" or something...
I never thought I would be in a spot with Dolly where I wouldn't want to sell her if the opportunity came up... Up until yesterday, I was ready to trade her or sell her to the first interested party! So, we'll see how things go tonight and maybe I'll have to make a tough decision...